Candidate drop-off: How to identify and fix your recruitment weak spots
July 17, 2023
So you have got a great job opening and plenty of interested candidates, but many seem to drop out of your hiring process before an offer is even made. What gives? The reality is, even the most promising candidates will lose interest if your recruitment experience leaves something to be desired.
The good news is, identifying and fixing the candidate drop-off points in your process can help turn things around. Think about your recruitment journey from a candidate’s perspective. Are there any parts that seem overly complicated, time-consuming, or opaque? Any black holes where communication goes dark for days or weeks? Candidates today expect a streamlined experience with plenty of updates and transparency.
A few common problem areas to review:
The application process: Is your application lengthy or confusing? Can candidates easily save progress and return later?
The interview scheduling: Do you schedule interviews promptly while candidate interest is high? Are you providing details about what to expect, who will be there, and how long it may take?
Candidate Communication: Are you updating the candidates on the progress of their applications? Are you being able to address their queries without delay? Are you able to guide them throughout the application/recruitment process?
With some refinement, you can turn candidate drop-off into candidate delight. A great experience will keep top talent engaged–and excited to join your team!
Understanding the causes of candidate drop-offs
A high candidate drop-off rate is frustrating, but the good news is there are things you can do about it. The first step is understanding why promising applicants lose interest in the process.
A cumbersome application process is a major turnoff. If your form is tedious to complete with too many steps or sections, candidates may abandon it halfway through. Keep applications concise and only ask for information you really need at this stage.
Lack of communication is another culprit. If candidates don’t hear from you for days or weeks after applying, they’ll likely assume the role has been filled and move on. Send an email within a week confirming you received their application and when they can expect to hear from you next.
An uninspiring job listing won’t motivate candidates to see the process through. Make sure your ad highlights the exciting and meaningful parts of the role, the impact they can have, opportunities for growth, and what’s in it for them. Help them visualize why this job would be appealing and worth the effort.
Finally, an inefficient interview process where candidates must repeat themselves to different people or go through too many rounds of interviews may discourage them from continuing, especially for an entry-level role. Streamline your process and be mindful of candidates’ time.
The key is to look at your process from the candidate’s perspective and make it as simple, engaging, and considerate as possible. With a few adjustments, you can turn applicant drop-offs into applicant drop-ins. Focus on clear communication, an efficient process, and selling the opportunity – your hiring metrics will thank you.
The impact of a lengthy recruitment process
A lengthy recruitment process can negatively impact both the candidate experience as well as your own hiring goals. Candidates today have more options and shorter attention spans. If your process drags on for weeks or months, there is a good chance top candidates will drop out or lose interest.
Frustration and confusion
Not knowing where they stand or what to expect next leads to frustration for candidates. They may feel like they’re in limbo and start to question whether the role or company is the right fit after all. Confusion around the next steps or delays in communication reflects poorly on your company and brand. Be transparent in setting expectations upfront about your process and timeline. Follow up regularly to keep candidates engaged.
Hiring the wrong candidate
The more time that elapses, the more opportunities there are for good candidates to find other offers. You may end up having to settle for a “second choice” candidate just to fill the role. Rush the process, and you risk not conducting a thorough assessment and hiring someone who isn’t the best fit. It’s a balancing act to move quickly while still making a thoughtful choice.
Loss of productivity
A prolonged recruitment process slows down your ability to fill roles and meet business needs. Teams remain short-staffed, and current employees take on extra work to compensate. Morale and productivity suffer as a result.
To speed up your process without sacrificing quality, look for ways to tighten timelines, reduce bureaucracy, improve communication, and make better use of screening tools and automation. The rewards of an optimized recruitment process are well worth the effort. Candidates will have a better experience, you’ll hire the best people faster, and your business will benefit from increased productivity and performance.
The role of clear communication in candidate retention
Clear communication is key to keeping candidates engaged in your hiring process. When candidates don’t understand the next steps or feel like they are left hanging with no updates, their enthusiasm fades and they start looking elsewhere.
To avoid confusion and keep candidates interested, establish a consistent communication cadence and messaging. Let candidates know what to expect regarding response times and next steps. Provide timelines and updates, even if just to say there is no update but you appreciate their patience.
Be transparent in your communication. Explain why additional interviews or assessments are needed and how they fit into the overall process. Share details about the role, team, company goals, or values to help candidates determine if the position is the right fit. The more they know, the more invested they will be.
Make communication a two-way street. Encourage candidates to ask questions and provide feedback. Not only does this show you value their input, but it gives insight into their priorities and needs which helps ensure a good match if an offer is extended.
Respond promptly to all inquiries and follow through on promises like sending resources or next steps. Even if it is just a quick message to acknowledge receipt of their email, timely responses demonstrate your reliability and keep the conversation going.
From the initial application to the final offer, effective communication and a positive candidate experience are vital. By being open, honest, and consistent you build trust, gain buy-in, and motivate candidates to see the process through to the end. Keep talking, keep listening, and you will have a much better chance of candidates accepting that offer letter when the time comes!
Leveraging technology to improve the candidate experience
Leveraging technology is key to improving the candidate experience and reducing drop-off. Candidates today expect a streamlined, user-friendly process. If your recruitment technology feels outdated or clunky, top candidates may abandon your process in frustration.
Set up automated communication to keep candidates informed on the status of their applications. Let them know when the application is received, if anything is missing, when they have been selected for an interview, etc. Automating communications takes the burden off your team and gives candidates peace of mind, reducing the likelihood of them accepting another offer before hearing back.
Applicant tracking system
Using an applicant tracking system (ATS) helps organize candidate information and the recruitment workflow. A good ATS allows you to post jobs, receive and review applications, schedule interviews, check references, and make hiring decisions all in one place. For candidates, an ATS provides a single access point to check on their application status, upload documents, choose interview time slots, and more. The more you can consolidate the process through technology, the better the experience for all involved.
Seamless interview scheduling
Nothing frustrates candidates more than an endless back-and-forth trying to schedule an interview. Use interview scheduling tools to provide candidates with a link where they can view available times and book their own interview slots. This simple step can make a big difference, especially for passive candidates who may have less flexibility or patience in their schedule.
Leveraging the right technology at each stage of your recruitment process helps create an experience candidate won’t want to drop out of. When the journey is easy and engaging, you will find more of the best candidates to make it all the way to the finish line.
So there you have it, the top ways to plug those candidate leaks in your hiring process. Make the application easy, reach out personally, keep candidates warm, and speed things up. Do that and you’ll see more great talent make it to the finish line. Remember, every single candidate interaction shapes their view of your company. Put in the work to make it a great experience and you’ll build a reputation as an employer of choice. Before you know it, you’ll have to beat candidates off with a stick! Okay, maybe not literally. But you get the point. Tighten up that recruitment process and next time you have an opening, you’ll have an eager pool of qualified candidates to choose from.
Join our mailing list and stay updated on recruitment automation news & trends.
Thanks for your interest! We'll get back to you soon